Warning: Parameter 1 to wp_default_scripts() expected to be a reference, value given in /home/futbol/public_html/wp-includes/plugin.php on line 601
Is David Silva better than Xavi, Iniesta and Fabregas? | El Centrocampista
Warning: Parameter 1 to wp_default_styles() expected to be a reference, value given in /home/futbol/public_html/wp-includes/plugin.php on line 601
El Centrocampista

IS DAVID SILVA SPAIN’S BEST MIDFIELDER? – The Manchester City man has the stats

silva

It is fair to say that Manchester City playmaker David Silva will not have particularly enjoyed his 26th birthday today.

He may have taken the Premier League by storm since his arrival from Valencia eighteen months ago, but with his team three-nil down to rivals Manchester United, the Spaniard was sacrificed at half time as manager Roberto Mancini looked to reorganise a defence that had earlier lost its leader Vincent Kompany to an absurd red card.

Such is the impact that the diminutive midfielder has had at Manchester City, the decision to remove Silva was seen by many at the Ethiad Stadium this afternoon as the almost unthinkable.

Widely regarded as the first name on his manager’s team sheet, Silva is currently enjoying cult status with the Premier League leaders.

Venture outside the Ethiad Stadium on a match day and it is little surprise to discover that a t-shirt bearing the slogan that simply reads “Keep calm and give it to Silva” is a best seller.

In the eyes of many Manchester City fans – when David Silva is on the pitch, everything is going to be alright.

And with a season that has to date yielded five goals and ten assists in 17 appearances for the blues, this is something that it is hard to argue against.

Those who questioned whether Silva could adapt to the English games have been made to look rather foolish.

Worth remembering that this is only his second season in England, a tantalising thought for many City fans must be that there is more to come.

That however, is probably just being greedy.

But despite his scintillating performances for his club thus far, international recognition is something that still alludes with his role considered ‘bit part’ rather than ‘starring’.

A victim of his national team’s almost embarrassing array of talent – especially in those midfield areas – Silva has been frustrated by his lack of a regular starting berth.

Rather ominously for Silva is the fact that Barcelona trio of Iniesta, Xavi and Fabregas all ahead of him in Del Bosque’s plans.

But although there is little doubt that these three players are not wonderfully gifted in their own right, are they any better than David Silva at the moment?

Statistics seem to indicate not.

When looking at assists so far this season, it is clear that there is only one winner with Silva averaging one assist every two games. Fabregas comes in a second with a respectable one in every 2.4 games, while both Iniesta and Xavi average one every three games.

While it could be argued that with Manchester City in free flowing goal scoring form at the moment, assisting goals isn’t that hard, let’s just remember that Iniesta and co are feeding the likes of Messi on a weekly basis.

On the goal scoring front both Silva and Xavi have five for their clubs domestically this season, Fabregas fares slightly better with eight, while Iniesta hasn’t found the back of the net thus far.

And if your still not convinced as to the midfield schemer’s attributes, then perhaps you would be wise to take a close look at his time spent with Valencia in La Liga.

In his 36 appearances during his last season at the Mestalla, Silva notched up ten goals and assisted thirteen.

As a way of comparison, Iniesta has never domestically scored ten goals in his ten season career with Barcelona so far.

Invaluable at Valencia as well as Manchester City, Silva formed a lethal combination with David Villa which at times seemed to carry Valencia to victory more often than not.

It was perhaps this fact then that made Valencia coach Unai Emery once comment:

“Logically Kaka has won more and done more in the game, but David is heading that way with steady performances. If I had to choose either, I’d stay with David.”

High praise indeed; so why is it then that David Silva keeps getting overlooked?

The player himself offers a fascinating explanation as to why he feels that this may be the case.

“Whether my situation would have been different if I played for Barcelona or Real Madrid? To be honest, I sometimes get the feeling that I would be treated differently if I had joined one of those two teams.”

It’s an allegation that all in the Spanish Football Federation will no doubt be quick to quash, but perhaps there is a deep rooted inclining to go with all things Real and Barcelona.

Considering the stature of both clubs in the game its perhaps understandable, but maybe just maybe David Silva is an example of what happens when you focus solely on the two giants.

Ask anyone in the Ethiad Stadium and confusion reigns as to why their little genius isn’t receiving the recognition from his country that he undoubtedly deserves.

As it turns out, everything nearly was okay in the end for Manchester City who produced a brave and defiant second half performance that acted as a prompt reminder as to why they are currently sitting top of the league.

Despite eventually losing 3-2, any reservations that Roberto Mancini may previously have had about whether his side has the mental strength to keep in pole position, must surely now have subsided.

David Silva may have a Premier League medal in his hand come May, but what he wants more than anything is for more Spanish caps on his head.




5 Comments

  1. Pingback: Fan Feedr FA Cup Reaction - Manchester City 2 vs. Manchester United 3 | FanFeedr News

  2. Really?

    9 January, 2012 at 00:12

    Fabregas is Spains best midfielder, look at this article from last year (he has massively improved since then)

    http://www.goal.com/en-gb/news/2896/premier-league/2011/02/23/2365923/stats-show-arsenal-midfielder-cesc-fabregas-is-most-creative

    Fabregas has already scored 9 la liga goals in this season plus assists. He has seen opportunities himself rather than wasting a pass on an ill-positioned team-mate.

    Silva is great but he is yet another overrated player. When people say he’s the best in the PL they forget what other players are achieving. Van Persie is probably the best in the PL right now. Cesc is underrated, possibly the best midfielders in the world.

  3. Derek Charles

    9 January, 2012 at 18:40

    Typical Anglo-centric, short-sighted analysis. The reason Silva isn’t playing in midfield for Spain is that midfield play (as any schoolboy will tell you) is about positioning and passing, virtues that allow you to set the rhythm and pace to the game and to orchestrate goals not by assisting necessarily but by assisting the assister. In that sense Xavi and Iniesta are peerless as they are involved (together) in nearly every goal Barcelona score. They also play a lot deeper than Silva or Fabregas so as to better control the game and their discipline keeps them there as opposed to running out of position on the off chance that they might score a goal – and thereby disrupting the team’s midfield positioning and therefore the team’s possession (this is something Cesc still has to learn because while his goals are helping Barca, his positioning has been damaging them). In short, mid-field play is about positioning and passing and Silva doesn’t even feature on the same radar as Xavi and Iniesta do when it comes to those critical virtues. And that is not even debatable!! “Silva better than Xavi and Iniesta”!! – do you hear yourselves when you say this nonsense!

  4. Derek Charles

    9 January, 2012 at 18:53

    And I notice that you didn’t compare Xavi, Iniesta, or even Busquets’ pass completion and accuracy stats with Silva’s. Is it because these more important midfield stats (yes, for a midfielder they are more important than goals and assists) dwarf Silva’s? If you’re going to present stats to back up an argument, even a straw-man argument, present all the stats – not a selective segment.

  5. Jafar

    9 January, 2012 at 23:35

    Guys Silva is the best player in the Premier League and he is the best Spanish player. States don’t matter, Silva creates more chances than Xavi who is the player has created the most chances over the last 5 years.
    There is no way Silva will have a more passes or passes complete than any of the Barca midfielders because his team doesn’t play on that, rather they play on him creating chances and finding open space. You should rememeber that to complete any pass you need to players and because of the other players at City Silva won’t be able to pass more, there is more the the midfield than passes alone.
    Also your passing accuracy doesn’t depend on the amount of passes you complete but rather the difficult of it.
    The way Silva plays is more about touch/technique and dribble rather than passing. In his Valencia day Banega was the better passer but his movement and play was his game. Dismissing him because he doesn’t complete as many passes as any of the Barca midfielders is just ignorant.
    He is a different type of player compared to Iniesta,Xavi,Xabi and Cesc.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Follow us and get La Liga news right in your feed!